This site is best viewed in landscape mode.
Listed / 01.22.14

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Mascaras Mother Nature Wouldn't 'Lash' Out Against!

Prepare to feast your eyes on luxe and lustrous mascaras that boast natural formulas and go the extra mile to boost, build and nurture lashes with each and every stroke. This season's wands are magical and are catching all eyes, thanks to rich coats, sleek brushes and promises of no dripping, flaking or breakage. So glide through for ten of the best, most highly rated natural mascaras, because if eyes are the windows to the soul, you'll want yours flashing a pair of mother nature approved ooh la la lashes!

Best Natural Mascaras - 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara, $18

100% Pure's Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara quenches the thirst of dry and dull lashes with a fruit and Black Tea formula that gently conditions without getting messy.

Buy at: Dermstore, Amazon

  • Smudge proof
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
Price: $18Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
100% Pure - Natural Mascaras:Buy at DermstoreBuy at Amazon
Best Natural Mascaras - Dr. Hauschka Skin Care Volume MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Dr. Hauschka Skin Care Volume Mascara, $30

Set your sights on Dr. Hauschka Skin Care's Volume Mascara for a smoothing, strengthening and quick drying coat that brings volume without the clumps.

Buy at: BeautyBar, Amazon

  • Smudge proof
  • Safe for all skin types and sensitive eyes
Price: $30Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Dr. Hauschka Skin Care - Natural Mascaras:Buy at BeautyBarBuy at Amazon
Best Natural Mascaras - Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara, $19

Sensitive eyes and suffering lashes will love Tarte's Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara for its reparative qualities that make it a brilliant choice for restoring lash health.

Buy at: Sephora, Ulta

  • Paraben, sulfate, synthetic and GMO free
  • Clinically proven to improve lash health
Price: $19Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Tarte - Natural Mascaras:Buy at SephoraBuy at Ulta
Best Natural Mascaras - Physicians Formula Organic Wear MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Physicians Formula Organic Wear Mascara, $10

As good to the eyes as it is to the Earth, Physicians Formula's Organic Wear Mascara coats, covers and boosts lashes without breaking, flaking or skipping a beat!

Buy at: Drugstore.com, Ulta

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Fragrance free
Price: $10Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Physicians Formula - Natural Mascaras:Buy at Drugstore.comBuy at Ulta
Best Natural Mascaras - Zuzu Luxe MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Zuzu Luxe Mascara, $16

Take your eyes from mediocre to modish with ZuZu Luxe Mascara's non-irritating and richly-hued formula. Safe for contact lens wearers, this mascara goes the extra lengths to give all lashes some extra length!

Buy at: Amazon, Pharmaca

  • Smudge proof
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Price: $16Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Zuzu Luxe - Natural Mascaras:Buy at AmazonBuy at Pharmaca
Best Natural Mascaras - bareMinerals Flawless Definition MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

bareMinerals Flawless Definition Mascara, $18

Your eyes will say it all with bareMinerals' Flawless Definition Mascara. A rich black formula and sleek 360 wand vow to leave lashes at their darkest, longest and flirtiest!

Buy at: Sephora, Ulta

  • Smudge proof
  • Paraben free
Price: $18Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
bareMinerals - Natural Mascaras:Buy at SephoraBuy at Ulta
Best Natural Mascaras - Jane Iredale 'Longest Lash' Thickening & Lengthening MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Jane Iredale 'Longest Lash' Thickening & Lengthening Mascara, $33

Give your eyes wings with Jane Iredale's 'Longest Lash' Thickening & Lengthening Mascara. Featuring a savvy defining brush, it gives lashes a naturally long and lush appearance with each and every sweep.

Buy at: BeautyBar, Nordstrom

  • Reduces splitting and breaking
  • Free of lacquers, shellac and petroleum-based ingredients
Price: $33Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Jane Iredale - Natural Mascaras:Buy at BeautyBarBuy at Nordstrom
Best Natural Mascaras - Lavera Double Black MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Lavera Double Black Mascara, $23

Getting the ultimate falsies effect is as easy as 1, 2 with Lavera's Double Black Mascara. Two precision brushes come together for one goal: to create long, strong and full lashes in just the blink of an eye!

Buy at: Drugstore.com, Walgreens

  • Dermatologically and opthalmologically tested
Price: $23Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Lavera - Natural Mascaras:Buy at Drugstore.comBuy at Walgreens
Best Natural Mascaras - Josie Maran Gogo Instant Natural Volume Argan MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Josie Maran Gogo Instant Natural Volume Argan Mascara, $22

For insta-volume and a speedy curl, Josie Maran's GOGO Instant Natural Volume Argan Mascara has got you and your lashes covered! A hydrating formula glides on smooth with serious staying power while leaving lashes healthy in between uses.

Buy at: Sephora, Amazon

  • Smudge proof
  • Paraben, sulfate and synthetic free
Price: $22Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Josie Maran - Natural Mascaras:Buy at SephoraBuy at Amazon
Best Natural Mascaras - Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes! Waterproof MascaraPin It!

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes! Waterproof Mascara, $19

Get picture perfect peepers with Tarte's Lights, Camera, Splashes! Waterproof Mascara that lengthens, curls, volumizes and conditions while staying in place even when you don't!

Buy at: Sephora, Ulta

  • Paraben, sulfate and synthetic free
  • Clinically proven to increase lash curl
Price: $19Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Tarte - Natural Mascaras:Buy at SephoraBuy at Ulta

The Ten Best Natural Mascaras

Mascaras Mother Nature Wouldn't 'Lash' Out Against!

Replay Slideshow
  • Best Natural Mascaras - 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Dr. Hauschka Skin Care Volume Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Physicians Formula Organic Wear Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Zuzu Luxe Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - bareMinerals Flawless Definition Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Jane Iredale 'Longest Lash' Thickening & Lengthening Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Lavera Double Black Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Josie Maran Gogo Instant Natural Volume Argan Mascara
  • Best Natural Mascaras - Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes! Waterproof Mascara
  • “Rank and Style is always the first place I go to find the best products.

    I was never that person to spend hours reading reviews or browsing through options which usually meant I either didn't buy the product or ended up buying the wrong one.” – Lauren, Tech Entrepreneur, 26

Lists Just For You...