This site is best viewed in landscape mode.

The Ten Best Black Mascaras

Best Black Mascaras - Benefit BADgal Waterproof MascaraPin It!

Benefit BADgal Waterproof Mascara

, $19

Benefit’s gel-based waterproof formula will stand up to the wear and tear of your day. Flake-free, easy application with an extra-long wand makes this a solid daily option.

Buy at SephoraBuy at Birchbox

Price: $19Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Benefit - Black Mascaras:
  • “Rank & Style is like my BuzzFeed for shopping...

    I love their lists, rankings I can trust and a site that saves me time.” – Mayuri, Working Mom, 34

Top Ten Lists You Might Like: