This site is best viewed in landscape mode.

The Ten Best Eyeliner Pencils

Best Eyeliner Pencils - Make Up For Ever Aqua EyelinerPin It!

Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyeliner

, $19

Made For: Fans of not just neutrals, but brights like fuchsia and lime

Buy at Sephora

  • Waterproof
  • Long wearing, fade-proof and smudgeable
  • 0.04 oz.
Price: $19Scoring Strength:
Add to Favorites:
Make Up For Ever - Eyeliner Pencils:
  • “As an avid online shopper, I rely heavily on user reviews and ratings...

    Rank & Style saves me time on browsing and research with its trusty algorithm-based ranking system so I don’t spend hours sifting through reviews on different sites.” – Jane, Fashionista, 31

Top Ten Lists You Might Like: