Collections

Drugstore Staff Favorites

Our Team’s Go-To Drugstore Beauty Finds for Gorgeous Skin, Hair, and More

Image credits: maybelline

Welcome to In Our Carts, a series where we take a break from the usual and share the products currently topping our team’s own shopping wish lists.

If there’s one thing we love, it’s a good drugstore beauty buy. We’re talking high-quality products that deliver results just as impressive—if not better—than their luxury counterparts, all without breaking the bank. And with the amount of beauty shopping we do (trust us, it's a lot), it only makes sense to share the drugstore staples that have earned a permanent spot in our routines. After all, recommending the best of the best is what we do. So, here’s what we’ve rounded up for you: our team’s absolute favorite drugstore beauty buys.

These are the holy grail products we swear by—the ones we repurchase without hesitation and recommend to anyone who’ll listen. From a cult-favorite mascara to a cuticle remover guaranteed to level up your at-home nail care routine, discover the drugstore gems our staff can’t live without. Oh, and the best part? Most of the products on this list are available on Amazon, so you can have them at your door in just a few clicks. Keep scrolling, and let us introduce you to some must-have drugstore beauty buys.

All products and deals are sourced by the Rank & Style team using data and expert insights. If you shop through our links, we may earn a commission—at no extra cost to you.

Jump To Products

April 22, 2025

FacebookPinterest logoTwitter logoEmail icon
Image credits: amazon

amazon

L'Oreal Paris Makeup True Match Lumi Glotion

$17

$14

Buy Now

"Mix a little of this in with your moisturizer in the AM and you'll have bronzed, glowing skin."—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

L'Oreal Paris Makeup Double Extend Tubing Mascara

$14

$10

Buy Now

"I switched to tubing mascara and will never go back."—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

La Roche Posay Toleriane Hydrating Facial Cleanser

$18

Buy Now

"This is a face wash I always keep on hand in my bathroom. It's hyrdating, gentle, and lasts forever."—Meredith Rimmer, Editorial Director

Kristin Ess Dry Finish Working Texture Spray

$15

Buy Now

"After trying what felt like every texture spray at the drugstore, this one came out on top. It works amazingly well, and the packaging is super chic—I love it."—Meredith Rimmer, Editorial Director

E.l.f. Cosmetics Halo Glow Liquid Filter

$14

$13

Buy Now

"I use this instead of foundation in the summer and my skin glows!"—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

Aquaphor Healing Ointment Advanced Therapy Skin Protectant

$7

$6

Buy Now

"No other lip balm works for me the way Aquaphor does."—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

Maybelline Lifter Gloss

$11

$9

Buy Now

"A great, affordable lip gloss. I keep one in every purse."—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

Blue Cross Cuticle Remover Cream

$6

Buy Now

"A cheap and effective cuticle cream. The bottle applicator also works extremely well."—Meredith Rimmer, Editorial Director

Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water

$20

Buy Now

"This has been a staple in my routine for years. I don’t use it daily, but it’s perfect for those times when I need a quick cleanse or to remove makeup in a pinch—it works like a charm."—Meredith Rimmer, Editorial Director

Weleda Skin Food

$19

$15

Buy Now

"My go-to moisturizer for years now—it hydrates like no other and results instantly-glowing skin."—Beth Zerdecki, Site Director

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer

$16

Buy Now

"For a matte, no-shine bronze, this is my absolute favorite formula. It smells great, too!"—Beth Zerdecki, Site Director

CeraVe Hydrating Facial Cleanser

$17

Buy Now

"I love this facial cleanser for everyday use. Cleanses and hydrates just as well as its more expensive counterparts."—Beth Zerdecki, Site Director

Pantene Daily Moisture Renewal Shampoo & Conditioner Set

$20

Buy Now

"My hair always feels its best after a wash and conditioning treatment with this duo."—Beth Zerdecki, Site Director

Milani Baked Blush In Berry Amore

$9

Buy Now

"This has been my go-to blush for years. It's cheap and gives the best sunkissed glow."—Taylor DeBaylo, Senior Brand Partnerships Manager

Neutrogena Beach Defense Water-Resistant SPF 50+ Sunscreen Stick

$13

$10

Buy Now

"Smells great, easy application, and the kids love it too."—Beth Zerdecki, Site Director

Arm & Hammer Advance White Toothpaste

$16

Buy Now

"I have only been using this toothpaste for a few weeks, and I can already see a visible difference."—Taylor DeBaylo, Senior Brand Partnerships Manager

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Double Repair Face Moisturizer

$25

$22

Buy Now

"This is my daily face moisturizer because it's lightweight and has SPF."—Georgia Jones, Site Merchandising Associate

Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara

$12

$10

Buy Now

"This is my favorite drugstore mascara. I always like to keep a backup in my bag, and this is the one I reach for every time."—Meredith Rimmer, Editorial Director

Harry's Body Wash In Fig

$12

Buy Now

"My husband and I have been using this body wash for years, and many guests have fallen in love with it, too. It smells very luxurious."—Taylor DeBaylo, Senior Brand Partnerships Manager

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Moisturizing Lip Gloss In Berry Brown

$8

Buy Now

"I have repurchased this lip gloss a few times. The berry brown is such a pretty color, and I'm always reaching for it in my bag."—Taylor DeBaylo, Senior Brand Partnerships Manager

View All Top 10 Lists
Arrow white

The Latest

Image credits: e.l.f. cosmetics

Beauty

Summer Beauty Dupes

Meet the Affordable Beauty Dupes That Are Just as Good as the Originals

View All Collections
arrow

Top Sale Finds

Image credits: athleta

Athleta

Mothers Day Sale: 25% off your purchase at Athleta.com!

Shop Now

Arrow white

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.