Top 10 Aftershave Products

Proven Aftershaves That Will Soothe And Calm Irritated Skin

Proven Aftershaves That Will Soothe And Calm Irritated Skin

If the thought of aftershave conjures up images of Kevin McCallister's iconic scream in Home Alone, we're here to tell you that the shaving essential has come a long way since those days. Originally created as an alcohol-based antisceptic that disinfected cuts and hurt like heck, today's versions are typically alcohol-free, and there are tons of different options out there—think lotions, gels, tonics, balms, and beyond. Many of them target different skin concerns, too, whether that's dryness, oiliness, or even acne, so if you're not using one, you're kind of doing your complexion a disservice. But fret not, because below, we've rounded up the Top 10 aftershave products on the internet so you don't have to embark on an endless search through the skincare aisles. From splurge-worthy options to top-rated drugstore finds, keep scrolling to see the products that made the cut and shop your favorites. Opening image: @baxterofca

Did you like our 10 Best After Shave Products? Shop all our Top 10 Mens lists to discover more top-ranked finds!  

Jump To Products

February 25, 2020

FacebookPinterest logoTwitter logoEmail icon

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings

Dior Sauvage After-Shave Lotion
Rank & Style Approved


Dior Sauvage After-Shave Lotion

LOVED FOR: Soothing formula aside, reviewers and their significant others alike rave that the scent is phenomenal. With notes of bergamot and ambergris, it nails the perfect balance of attention-grabbing but not over-the-top.

COMPLETE THE LOOK: You'll probably want to grab the coordinating cologne once you smell this stuff.

Clinique Exfoliating Tonic

BEST FOR: If you want something that's luxe but doesn't break the bank, Clinique's Exfoliating Tonic is a top-notch option. And since the formula is a gentle tonic rather than a heavy lotion, it's a particularly perfect choice for those with oily skin—it'll keep those pores clean and clear.

HELPFUL TIP: Try using it before you shave to exfoliate and prep the skin before your razor goes to work, then use it after too.

Tend Skin After Shave Solution

WHAT IT DOES: Formulated with acetylsalicylic acid (a fancy term for aspirin), this seriously soothing aftershave is perfect for kicking nicks, cuts, and razor bumps to the curb. And don't worry—it doesn't burn.

HELPFUL TIP: It's tough to overdo it with this product since it's packed with so many skin-loving ingredients, so it's safe to use this as much as you please. We recommend applying it both morning and night until the skin heals, then daily and after hair removal.

The Art Of Shaving After Shave Balm

BEST FOR: If your skin is dry or dehydrated, this sandalwood-scented shave balm is your match. It's full of hydrating ingredients like shea butter, glycerin, essential oils, and grapeseed extract, so it quickly rejuvenates and soothes the skin after hair removal.

USERS SAID: "Most sandalwood scents that I have tried in the past left me smelling like an old man, however this one is fantastic. It's so soothing and moisturizing—I highly recommend this and their sandalwood shaving soap as well."

Nivea Sensitive Post Shave Balm

BEST FOR: Sensitive-skinned guys, this one's for you. Nivea's ultra-gentle formula contains moisturizers, vitamins, and chamomile extracts that combine to soothe and calm skin that's irritated after shaving. 

FUN FACT: This unique formula doesn't just provide short-term improvement, but long-term too. With continued use, it'll improve the skin's defense over time and keep redness and sensitivity at bay.

Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

LOVED FOR: This post-shave gel provides an instant cooling effect that feels oh-so-good after shaving, and it smells fantastic too. It's a win-win.

WHY YOU NEED IT: It also doubles as a lightweight moisturizer to prevent flaking and dryness, so it's pretty much two products for the price of one.

Baxter Of California After Shave Balm

WHAT IT DOES: This one boasts a lot of benefits besides just looking cool in your Dopp kit. Not only does it keep razor burn away thanks to aloe and tea tree oil, but it also works to protect the skin from the visible signs of aging.

USERS SAID: "I started using this shaving balm about a year and a half ago, and it is probably my favorite product to use on my face, not only because it's effective, but also because it's like getting a reward for shaving which gets tedious and often feels like a chore. This balm is beyond refreshing and I look forward to shaving because I know it's an excuse to use the product when I'm done. Another plus is that the tube lasts forever and a little bit goes a long way."

Duke Cannon Supply Co. Ice Cold After Shave Balm

LOVED FOR: Made with menthol, this balm provides a super unique cooling effect that helps close pores and provides instant comfort. You'll be looking for excuses to shave just so you can use this—trust us.

USERS SAID: "I shaved my head, and it can get pretty sensitive. This stuff feels amazing and smells great too. If I was any less of a man, I would consider shaving my beard off just to be able to use it on my face. I highly recommend."

Shaveworks The Cool Fix Targeted Gel Lotion

BEST FOR: Ideal for both ladies and gents alike, this unique formula tackles ingrown hairs like no other. It contains an effective combo of exfoliating agents that help release trapped hairs from underneath the skin, kill bacteria, and prevent those pesky ingrown from ever coming back.

HELPFUL TIP: Don't let the scent steer you away—it's strong, but it fades quickly and according to reviewers, the results are well worth it.

Proraso After Shave Lotion

WHY YOU NEED IT: There's a reason this stuff has been around for years—it's a true classic. It's great for keeping pores tight and tiny, it's gentle enough to use every day, and it rings up under $15. You may as well just buy two right now.

HELPFUL TIP: Although it's skin-friendly, this formula does have alcohol in it. We recommend dabbing a bit on a washcloth and diluting it with water to start.

View All Top 10 Lists
Arrow white

The Latest

Image credits: fair harbor

Activewear & Swim

Top 10 Men's Swim Trunks

According to Guys, These Are The Best Swim Trunks To Buy Online

View All Mens

Top Sale Finds

Image credits: gap

Gap Sale

50% off your purchase, including sale.

Shop Now

Arrow white

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.