10090807060504030201
Beauty/Makeup/Eyes/Eyeliners
Top 10 Eyeliners For Aging Eyes

These 10 No-Tug Eyeliners Work Wonders For Aging Eyes

We can splurge on all the anti-aging eye creams, serums, and masks our hearts desire, but sadly, there's nothing we can do to slow down the aging process. After years of squinting, smiling, and eyebrow-raising, our skin begins to change—most notably, the skin around our eyes. Due to natural occurrences, the products and techniques relied upon throughout the years don't offer the same results they once did, especially when it comes to eyeliner.

While we can't stop the clock, investing in quality products keeps our skin looking its best as it matures. This is when making the proper beauty swaps becomes absolutely necessary. Where aging skin is concerned, it's important to find an eyeliner that is long-lasting, gentle, and won't tug or crease upon application. You can trust that these tools won't feather or fade in crow's feet, fine lines, and wrinkles.

How We Found The Best Eyeliners For Aging Eyes

With the countless formulas the beauty world has to offer, finding the perfect eyeliner can require quite a bit of digging. Lucky for you, our algorithm has already found and ranked each one for you based on user reviews, editorial recommendations, best-seller lists, and more. Loved for their creamy textures that effortlessly glide across the lid and long-lasting staying power, you'll soon learn why reviewers with mature skin have dubbed these non-tug eyeliners as their favorites—keep scrolling to discover the Top 10.

Jump To List

September 22, 2022

Words:Rank & Style

Product Expert:Georgia Jones

FacebookEmail icon

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings


Clinique Quickliner for Eyes Eyeliner Pencil

Our Score

4.5

Best For Sensitive Eyes

WHAT IT DOES
As a Clinique eyeliner, this pencil formula is allergy-tested, ophthalmologist-approved, and fragrance-free. It's specifically designed to work well for aging skin because of its gentleness, but make sure to wait 60 seconds for the transfer resistance to completely set in.

HELPFUL TIP
Use the smudging tool on the opposite end to achieve the perfect look.

More Colors

More Colors


Almay All-Day Intense Gel Eyeliner

Our Score

4.55

Best Drugstore

USER REVIEW
"I’m trying to choose products with less harmful chemicals and this was it. This eyeliner does glide right on with ease. I’m in my 50’s so my eyelids are getting a little less firm and my previous liner always left a mark on my eyelid after about 30 minutes. This eyeliner stays put. I use a natural oil remover and it comes right off with little effort. Will definitely buy this again and will be referring it to my friends."

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
In addition to being hypoallergenic, this clean, creamy pencil liner is cruelty-free and ophthalmologist-tested. It leaves your skin safe from harmful ingredients such as parabens, phthalates, and formaldehydes.

More Colors

More Colors


Lancôme Artliner Precision Point Liquid Eyeliner

Our Score

4.6

Best Precision Tip

WHAT IT DOES
Thanks to the uniquely-shaped foam tip, Artliner allows you to create the coolest eye looks with ease. The liquid formula was built for precision thanks to its intense color and long-lasting, smudge-proof design.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
This fool-proof liner doesn't dry immediately, so you've got time to fix any mistakes.

More Colors

More Colors


Julep Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Our Score

4.6

Best Gel

WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT
The silky gel formula is easy to work into the lashline and gives the appearance of fuller, bolder lashes. It's ophthalmologist-tested for 10+ hour usage, making it a safe option for aging, sensitive skin.

USER REVIEW
"I have been using this brand for about a year now. It is the ONLY brand of eyeliner that does not make my eyes itch or smudge when using it."

More Colors

More Colors


Neutrogena Nourishing Eye Liner

Our Score

4.65

Best Nourishing

INGREDIENT SPOTLIGHT
While eyeliner can be harmful to the delicate skin around the eyes, this pencil is designed to combat that. It's filled with nourishing ingredients like shea butter and olive oil that help the formula glide on smoothly and moisturize the skin while doing so. As an extra bonus, this liner includes subtle light diffusers to further accentuate the color and make the whites of your eyes appear brighter.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
This eyeliner comes with a sharpener, so you don't have to look elsewhere to get ultimate precision.

More Colors

More Colors


Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil: Eye, Lip & Brow Pencil

Our Score

4.65

Best Multitasking

WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT
Make Up For Ever’s Artist Color Pencil is truly one-of-a-kind. In addition to its versatility—you can use it on the lips, brows, and face—it also comes in 19 bold shades with runway-worthy color payoff. No matter where you apply it, the matte formula goes on smoothly and blend perfectly.

APPLICATION TIP
Combine this with the brand’s Step 1 Eye & Lip Primer if you want longer wear.

More Colors

More Colors


Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Our Score

4.75

Best Color Range

WHAT IT DOES
The creamy texture smudges like a kohl pencil—a quality that's tough to find in waterproof formulas—so it's perfect for creating the boldest smokey eyes. With 22 different colors to choose from, there's no look that you can't achieve.

WHERE TO WEAR
No rom-com, muggy day, or hot yoga sesh is enough to make this stuff budge. It stays put all day but washes away easily with your cleanser.

More Colors

More Colors


Ilia Clean Line Gel Liner

Our Score

4.75

Best Clean Beauty

WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT
This squeaky-clean formula delivers an effortless glide and easy blendability. Plus, it boasts excellent color payoff and is water-resistant. As far as gel liners go, this is one of the best.

USER REVIEW
"I love this eyeliner! It glides on smoothly and stays put, but it's still easy to correct any mistakes. And the ingredients are something I feel good about. I won’t buy another brand! I’ve reordered multiple times."

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

Our Score

4.85

WHO IT'S FOR
If you like a subtle smudge, Revlon’s pencil is the one to add to your makeup bag. It’s been a mainstay for years, and for good reason: It glides on easily and the waterproof formula stands up to smearing—and even humidity.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
This eyeliner is in it for the long haul, lasting up to 24 hours with no blemishes.

More Colors

More Colors


Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Our Score

4.9

Best Overall

WHO IT'S FOR
Whether you want a fine line or bold cat eye, this liquid formula is perfect for the eyeliner novice. Thanks to its pen tip and rich formula, the application is smooth and precise with no smudging or pulling, so you don't need to worry about the effects of shaky hands.

USER REVIEW
"I just *love* Stila eyeliner! I’ve tried so many of them over the years, and Stila is not only the blackest, but the tip is thin enough to give me the perfect cat-eye, and the price is right! I’m a fan for life!"

More Colors

More Colors

The Latest

Primers

Top 10 Primers For Mature Skin

Hands Down, These Are The Best Primers For Aging Skin

View All Beauty
arrow

Top Sale Finds

Sephora's Gifting Event

Join Beauty Insider And Get 20% Off With Code: GETGIFTING.

Shop Now

Arrow white

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.