Shopping for beauty products online can sometimes feel like the wild, wild west. Outside the borders of a brick-and-mortar store, the options are seemingly endless, letting anxiety set in more easily. The key to a successful beauty haul is preparing ahead of time and ensuring that each item compliments the other. For example, under-eye setting powder may not be the most exciting product, but it's definitely one of the most important. It's an insurance policy for your concealer, and without it, under-eye coverage can go from flawless and smooth to creased and cakey fast, especially in warm weather.
So, why not just use a regular old setting powder? Because one formulated specifically for the under-eye area can work wonders. Unlike standard setting powder formulas that are finely milled and most likely transparent, many under-eye setting powders contain unique perfecting, blurring, and brightening benefits that make faking a full night’s sleep after staying up all night—hopefully for a fun reason—easier. It’s to the under-eye area what an eyeshadow primer is to the eyelids: it enhances the impact of its partner product, making the big finish all the more impressive.
Shoppers can’t get enough of the under-eye setting powders in this list, from the best drugstore under-eye setting powder to luxury buys offered in multiple shades. Also included are under-eye baking powders made with various textures in mind, from transparent and sheer to tinted formulas that can boost brightness and cover dark circles.
How We Found The Best Under-Eye Setting Powders
Rank & Style doesn’t play favorites. Instead, this Top 10 list was created with the help of a data-driven algorithm that factors in best-seller lists, user reviews, and industry recognition. Scroll ahead to see which under-eye setting powders made the cut.
Next up, check out the 10 Best Setting Powders.
June 28, 2022
Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.
Pat McGrath Labs Sublime Perfection Blurring Under-Eye Setting Powder
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Regular setting powder can be too heavy for the under-eye area, but this reviewer-favorite formula is super lightweight and virtually undetectable under the eyes. It has a delicate, silky texture that visibly blurs fine lines and imperfections, plus light-reflecting properties that deliver a luminous, lifted effect. Bye-bye, dark circles.
ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: This under-eye setting powder is non-comedogenic, so it's great for those with breakout-prone skin.
Huda Beauty Easy Bake Loose Baking & Setting Powder
WHO IT'S FOR: Formulated to provide up to 10 hours of wear and no flashback in photos, this loose powder is a must-have for those who prefer to use the baking technique. Thanks to neutral undertones, it delivers a flawless, brightened finish that enhances every skin tone and complexion.
ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: Available in a mini and full-sized option, this baking powder offers a lightweight, silky texture that melts into the skin and adds just a hint of sheen for a luminous finish.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Finish Setting Powder
WHAT IT DOES: Formulated with rose wax and almond oil for an extra hydrating touch, this skincare-makeup mashup blurs imperfections and visibly reduces shine while improving the complexion over time. Genius, huh?
USER REVIEW: "Omg, do not pass go. Buy it now! This product dusts on so perfectly and so evenly. I use it all over my face, but I also use it as a primer on my eyes and to help cover up the dark circles in the corners of my eyes. This is definitely a luxury product that’s both worth the hype and money. This is my new go-to setting powder."
BeautyCounter Mattifying Powder
WHO IT'S FOR: Suffer from oily, breakout-prone skin? Look no further. Sure, most under-eye powders will keep oil under control to an extent, but this formula means business. A single sweep of the smooth, translucent powder is all it takes to set makeup and expertly absorb shine for hours—all without leaving that dreaded white reside.
USER REVIEW: "This is MUST in my arsenal! It’s invisible, but it sets one’s makeup perfectly and it's great for dusting over a makeup-less face to add a touch of polish."
Fenty Beauty By Rihanna Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Setting Powder
WHAT IT DOES: Milled to superfine, silky perfection, this setting powder works to extend the longevity of your makeup look and blur the appearance of imperfections. Available in eight inclusive shades, the formula resists flashback and delivers a bright, smooth, shine-free complexion.
USER REVIEW: "The formula for this powder is incredible. I have very oily skin and was nervous to try it. The powder absorbs any excess oil and keeps my makeup in place for hours. I love the way it brightens my under eyes, and even the smell is great! Highly recommend."
Rare Beauty By Selena Gomez Always an Optimist Soft Radiance Setting Powder
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: In Selena's words, she wanted to create something that "performed like a setting powder but acted like skin." Long story short, she succeeded. According to the reviews (the vast majority of them being five stars), this stuff practically disappears into the skin but keeps concealer from budging for hours on end.
ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: Available in five shades from light to deep, this setting powder is an excellent option for all-over application.
Coty Airspun Loose Face Powder
WHY IT MADE THE LIST: According to rave reviews, this formula is a total dupe for the Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder. The cult favorite is beloved for its ability to beautifully lock down foundation without caking or creasing—even on the under-eye area. Coty Airspun is a close rival and rings up under $10.
HELPFUL TIP: If it's a little too lightweight for your liking, go with the Extra Coverage version.
Ilia Soft Focus Finishing Powder
WHO IT'S FOR: If your skin is super dry and you've pretty much given up on finding a setting powder that doesn't exacerbate the problem, go ahead and end your search here. Ilia's Soft Focus formula is made with aloe, rosemary, and oil-balancing bamboo to hydrate the skin while it keeps makeup in place.
USER REVIEW: "Wow! I’ve tried them all, and this is hands down the best setting powder. It blurs out your pores and sinks right into your skin. It's so brightening and makes your skin look hydrated. Go out and get it. I 100% recommend this."
Kosas Cloud Set Baked Setting & Smoothing Powder
WHY IT MADE THE LIST: It doesn’t get much dreamier than a setting powder that goes on like a mousse, blends down to a barely there texture that feels light as air, and tones down shine without taking away glow. Plus, the formula is enriched with plant oils and floral extracts that both nourish and improve the overall complexion.
APPLICATION TIP: Use this just about anywhere on the face to refresh makeup through the day, but apply it with a foundation brush for the most even coverage.
Laura Mercier Secret Brightening Powder
WHAT IT DOES: This talc-free formula has light-reflecting pigments that brighten, lighten, and create serious luminosity. Soft and weightless, it won't ever settle into fine lines, accentuate shadows, or build up on the skin. Consider it your fave Insta filter IRL.
AS SEEN ON: Makeup artist Kendra Mann is a big fan of this powder. Here's a pic of Mandy Moore for proof.