Top 10 Eye Makeup Removers

Removing Stubborn Waterproof Eye Makeup Just Got Easier

Removing Stubborn Waterproof Eye Makeup Just Got Easier

Our Top 10 Lists help shoppers quickly and easily find what they need. Using an intense review and approval process (which you can learn more about here), we break down the best styles according to what consumers most commonly search for and want.

It turns out it isn't just the right makeup that will make your eyes look bright and aglow. In fact, a case could be made that it really comes down to your eye makeup remover. After all, the eye area is the most delicate, tender part of your face, so leaving behind traces of stubborn mascara and harsh tugging could be doing more damage than you know. Start treating your under-eye skin with the respect it deserves by adding one of our Top 10 eye makeup removers to your nighttime routine. Made to simultaneously nourish skin as you remove the remains of the day, the following eye makeup removers come backed by our algorithm. From water-like textures to fragrance-free formulas, learn about the top eye makeup removers that reviewers from around the web use and love. 

Why Shop Our Best Eye Makeup Removers

Here at Rank & Style, we’re all about helping you buy things you love. Our mission is to make your shopping experience as simple as possible, because as much as we love a great return policy, we don’t think you should have to use it. To do this, we use an unbiased algorithm that finds the best products out there by factoring in best-selling buzz, editor recommendations, rave reviews, and more. It’s how we determined the following eye makeup removers are the best on the internet—and how we can confidently say you’ll love them, too.

Did you enjoy our 10 Best Eye Makeup Removers? Then we think you’ll really enjoy our 10 Best Dark Spot RemoversOpening image: @lancome

Jump To Products

November 9, 2021

FacebookPinterest logoTwitter logoEmail icon

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings

Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water
Rank & Style Approved


Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water

WHY IT MADE OUR LIST: This cult-favorite micellar water is about as good as it gets. Not only does it completely remove makeup and impurities with ease, but it leaves skin feeling refreshed and soothed for a healthy looking complexion.

WHY WE LOVE IT: "I have been mixing it up with cleansers lately, but I always use the Bioderma micellar water as the second step in my skincare routine. It removes any leftover makeup or grime, leaving my face super clean. I highly recommend the pump cap, too!”—Taylor DeBaylo, Site Merchandising Associate

Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

WHY IT MADE OUR LIST: The soothing ingredients and powerful results make this affordable makeup remover a top-seller. 

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: This product is ophthalmologist tested and safe for use around the eye area. 

Estée Lauder Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

WHY IT MADE OUR LIST: The gentle, lightweight formula leaves zero oily residue behind, so you can reapply eye makeup immediately afterwards if needed. 

USER REVIEW: "I have extremely sensitive eyes and this is the ONLY product that doesn't make my eyes/eye area feel like someone is clawing at my face. No burning, nothing. Totally recommend this and it does a fabulous job at removing makeup. Love the fact that I can stick a cotton swab inside to help remove my eyeliner from my tear duct area."

Clinique Rinse-Off Eye Makeup Solvent

WHY YOU NEED IT: From mascara to eyeliner to brow makeup, this formula works fast to get rid of it all without any irritation. 

BEST FOR: The non-irritating and oil-free formula makes this an excellent choice for all skin types. 

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermo Face Cleanser For Face & Eyes

WHY YOU NEED IT: Thanks to ingredients like glycerin and thermal water, this formula helps to prevent over-drying and soothe the skin as it cleanses.

HELPFUL TIP: You can use this just like you would a typical face cleanser or simply apply and remove with a cotton ball or wipe. 

Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

WHY YOU NEED IT: Warmer days often mean sweat, sun, sea, and—of course—long-wearing mascara. This eye makeup remover will melt away every last bit of it without irritating sensitive eyes.

FUN FACT: This formula contains lash-strengthening properties to beautify your lashes while it removes makeup.

Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

BEST FOR: Neutrogena's eye makeup remover won't hit you where it hurts when it comes to your wallet. Available at your local drugstore, it's a favorite of those on a beauty budget. 

USER REVIEW: "I won't use any other eye makeup remover. If you're looking for something that works and goes with sensitive skin this is the product for you."

Charlotte Tilbury Take It All Off Genius Eye Make-Up Remover

WHY YOU NEED IT: Two pumps is all it takes to remove even the most stubborn of eye makeup. It's also super effective for taking off lipstick. 

USER REVIEW: "This eye makeup remover is wonderful for very sensitive eyes. It removes mascara and shadow very gently but thoroughly and actually soothes the skin with cornflower. Non-drying and leaves no oily residue to irritate the skin later on. I'm very pleased with this."

Lancôme Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

BEST FOR: The extremely gentle formula is a dream for those with sensitive skin or who wear contacts.

USER REVIEW: “I have been using this product for 20 plus years and would not use anything else. I have tried other products along the way but nothing has even come close. It is effortless to remove waterproof mascara and eyeliner.”

Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water

WHAT IT DOES: Little micelle bubbles work hard to attract and remove all traces of dirt, oil, and makeup—without any harsh rubbing or pulling.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: Bonus: you can use this multipurpose cleanser to remove excess self-tanner from hands and feet immediately after application. 

View All Top 10 Lists
Arrow white

The Latest

Image credits: maybelline


Top 10 Drugstore Cult Beauty Buys

10 Drugstore Buys That Makeup Artists, Celebs, and Beauty Junkies Swear By

View All Beauty

From Our Partners

Image credits: renttherunway

Rent The Runway

The 10-item subscription plan is 40% off for a limited time!

Shop Now

Arrow white

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.