10090807060504030201
Beauty/Makeup/Eyes/Eyebrows

Top 10 Brow Pencils

Plain And Simple, These Are The 10 Best Eyebrow Pencils Of 2024

Image credits: bobbibrown

Over the last few years, eyebrows have become the feature to emphasize. Just check out TikTok if you have any doubts. From an eyebrow map filter that's supposed to help you achieve the best brows for your face shape to countless tutorials on the latest trends, it’s clear that your makeup routine isn’t complete without a great-looking brow. 

So, if you’re looking for the best way to get a beautiful brow without much fuss, let us suggest using a top-notch eyebrow pencil.  

A great brow pencil can help you define your eyebrows and improve your makeup's overall look. Whether you want a natural look for every day or a super-pigmented pencil to create a dramatic effect for a night out, the market is filled with options. But trying to figure out which product to pick to achieve your brow goals with all these choices can be challenging. Factors to consider when picking a pencil range from different formulas, features, and price points, not to mention trying to decide on a color.   

Luckily, we’re here for you, and we've rounded up the 10 best eyebrow pencils on the market. Whether you want to know how the best budget brow pencil compares to a luxury brand’s product or find a waterproof eyebrow pencil you can even swim in, we have all the details covered.  

How We Found The Best Eyebrow Pencils

Our Top 10 Lists are created using our unique algorithm that factors in things like reviews, best-seller lists, and beauty editor faves. With these unbiased results, you know you’re getting the best product options when you read our rankings. Whether you’re looking to try a brow pencil for the first time or want to add a new tool to your well-stocked makeup bag, the list below has you covered.

Jump To Products

May 9, 2024

Written By:Rank & Style

Product Expert:Georgia Jones

FacebookPinterest logoTwitter logoEmail icon

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings


10
Image credits: nordstrom
Rank & Style Approved

nordstrom

Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Long-Wear Brow Pencil

Overall Score

4.65

10

Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Long-Wear Brow Pencil

4.35

652 User Reviews

2.9

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Learn More
arrow

Best Eyebrow Pencil For Natural Brows

WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT
Bobbi Brown has long been the leader in natural-looking beauty, and this brow pencil is no exception. This product is long-lasting, waterproof, and sweat-resistant, so you can be sure whatever the day throws at you, your brows will look their best. Plus, with 11 colors to choose from, everyone is sure to find a great color match.  

HELPFUL TIP
Part of what helps this eyeliner provide such a natural look is the uniquely shaped tip. This video from Bobbi Brown shows you how to make the most out of this product.

More Colors

More Colors


Revlon Colorstay Waterproof Longwearing Eyebrow Pencil

Overall Score

4.7

09

Revlon Colorstay Waterproof Longwearing Eyebrow Pencil

4.54

16365 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

3

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Eyebrow Pencil For Beginners

WHAT IT DOES
This eyebrow pencil is perfect for beginners and pros alike because it creates precise, hair-like strokes that are soft and blendable. It's also waterproof, which means less touch-ups throughout the day.

APPLICATION TIP
To define the shape of your eyebrows, start by using the angled side of a brow pencil to create a soft line along the top and lower edges of your natural arch and tail. Then, use the flat side of the pencil to fill in your brows with short, feathery strokes.

More Colors

More Colors


Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Brow Pencil

Overall Score

4.85

08

Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Brow Pencil

4.36

1188 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Clean Eyebrow Pencil

WHY IT MADE THE LIST
Okay, this eyebrow pencil is truly exceptional. It has a micro triangle shape with a thicker side to fill in sparse areas and a thinner point for shaping and defining. The vegan wax-based formula provides rich color that won't smudge, fade, or transfer. Additionally, it contains castor oil, which nourishes and promotes the overall growth and health of your brow hairs. 

PROMISING REVIEW
"I have no tails on my brows... just "half-brows" from over plucking. This is the FIRST pencil that goes on to the bare skin with no pressure, it's smooth, doesn't skip, isn't waxy, and it stays all day.. It also makes the little flick or hair like thin strokes in the front without them being too thick.... It's just fast and easy. I can do a full brow in seconds. I'm a cheapskate most of the time, but I will pay full price for this, and I actually bought a back up which is unheard of for me..... It is one of my favorite makeup products that I own."

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free

Clean Beauty

Clean Beauty


NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil Vegan Eyebrow Pencil

Overall Score

4.85

07

NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil Vegan Eyebrow Pencil

4.52

20486 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Precision-Tip Eyebrow Pencil

WHY IT MADE THE LIST
This vegan eyebrow pencil has it all: a fine point for creating meticulous hair strokes and a well-saturated, creamy texture that can create full, dramatic brows!   

ABOUT THE BRAND
NYX is committed to making professional quality makeup available to everyone. Their highly pigmented, long-lasting, and always cruelty-free products are perfect for creating bold beauty looks.

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil

Overall Score

4.85

06

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil

4.59

75156 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Eyebrow Pencil For Sparse Brows

WHO IT’S FOR
This pencil is a favorite for those with thicker brows who are looking to fill in patchy areas and create a full, natural-looking shape. The pencil creates a seamless look with its slim tip that allows you to recreate the fine look of individual hairs with ease.

HELPFUL TIP
Anastasia has consistent naming across products in their brand, making it easy to find the right color products to mix and match while creating your dream brows.

More Colors

More Colors


Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

Overall Score

4.9

05

Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

4.5

2005 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Eyebrow Pencil For Fuller Brows

WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT
This product is a triple threat since it can do the work of powder, wax, and a pencil in one swipe. The formula is buildable, meaning you can easily layer it to create a thicker, fuller-looking brow.

ABOUT THE BRAND
Hourglass Cosmetics is a cruelty-free and vegan brand. In addition to taking a stand against animal testing, they donate a portion of their profits to an organization that supports animal rights.

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


E.l.f. Cosmetics Instant Lift Eyebrow Pencil

Overall Score

4.95

04

E.l.f. Cosmetics Instant Lift Eyebrow Pencil

4.5

51989 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Affordable Eyebrow Pencil

WHO IT’S FOR
The e.l.f pencil is another excellent choice for brow beginners. This product has a smooth, slightly creamy texture that makes blending easy while still being well-pigmented. At $3, it's a budget-friendly choice and a perfect way to experiment with eyebrow pencils.  

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
The e.l.f pencil contains grapeseed oil and vitamin E to help condition the hair and promote growth.

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Rare Beauty By Selena Gomez Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil

Overall Score

5

03

Rare Beauty By Selena Gomez Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil

4.67

881 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

WHAT IT DOES
Here's what to know: This brow pencil is waterproof, sweat- and oil-resistant. It comes with a fine-angled tip to create precise, hair-like strokes that give you the most natural-looking brows. It is not too creamy or waxy and applies smoothly and evenly with just the right amount of pigment for you to control.

WHY IT MADE THE LIST
This eyebrow pencil ranked high on our list due to its top-notch reviews. On Sephora alone, it has nearly 600 5-star reviews. 

More Colors

More Colors

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

Overall Score

5

02

Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

4.5

37708 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil

WHY IT MADE THE LIST
A tried-and-true favorite, Maybelline's Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer makes an excellent choice for anyone. Whatever your brow look, natural or dramatic, this brow pencil can get the job done. And at just $8, you'll be more than happy with the results. 

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
Unlike other spoolie brushes, this one is shorter, making it perfect for those who prefer smaller, fluffier brushes to blend out their brow makeup.

More Colors

More Colors


Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

Overall Score

5

01

Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

4.57

20991 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Eyebrow Pencil Overall

WHO IT'S FOR
For the woman looking for her perfect color match, these 12 shades run the gamut from light to dark and include cool, warm, and neutral tones, so there’s sure to be something for everyone. The smudge-proof staying power of this waterproof pencil makes sure that your magical match lasts all day long.  

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW
Smaller versions of the pencils are available in each of the 12 shades, so you can get a matching mini to take with you on the go.

More Colors

More Colors

View All Top 10 Lists
Arrow white

The Latest

Image credits: irisandromeo

Sun Protection & Care

Top 10 Tinted Sunscreens

10 Tinted Sunscreens That Pull Double Duty For Protection And Coverage

View All Beauty
arrow

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.