10090807060504030201
Beauty/Makeup/Eyes/Mascaras & Lashes

Top 10 Brown Mascaras

Love A More Natural-Looking Lash? Try One Of These Top-Rated Brown Mascaras

Image credits: sephora

If there's one thing we've learned from the ever-changing landscape of makeup trends, it's that natural beauty never goes out of style. While the days of pencil-thin eyebrows and neon eyeshadow may have come and gone, the current "cloud skin" trend serves as a reminder that enhancing our natural features is timeless. Enter brown mascara – the perfect way to add a subtle yet impactful twist to your makeup routine.

Brown mascara offers a more understated look compared to its classic black counterpart, yet it still delivers on length, volume, and curl. The warm tones in brown mascara can complement a variety of eye colors, from hazel to blue and green, enhancing their natural beauty with a touch of warmth.

Whether your eyes are deep brown or crystal blue, incorporating brown mascara into your beauty arsenal is a smart move, especially if you're a fan of the "no-makeup" makeup look. But with so many options on the market, it's essential to choose a brown mascara that delivers on its promises without clumps, smudges, or disappointments.

To help you find the perfect brown mascara for your needs, we've curated a list of the internet's top-rated options below. From lengthening formulas to volumizing wonders, these mascaras are sure to elevate your natural beauty game effortlessly (and confidently).

How We Found The Internet’s Best Brown Mascaras

You know the drill: In order to determine which products deserve a spot on our Top 10 lists, we put our data-powered ranking algorithm on the job. This tool uses information from reviews, best-seller lists, and social media in order to find and score the top options in a given category. Ahead, see which brown mascaras are giving shoppers good results, from recognizable names like Too Faced and Clinique to drugstore faves like Maybelline and L’Oreal Paris.

Jump To Products

March 6, 2024

Written By:Sierra Rogers

Product Expert:Georgia Jones

FacebookPinterest logoTwitter logoEmail icon

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings


10
Image credits: amazon
Rank & Style Approved

amazon

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara In Brown

Overall Score

4.65

10

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara In Brown

4.33

72241 User Reviews

4

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

3

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Learn More
arrow

Best Brown Mascara For Volume

WHAT TO KNOW
Covergirl's Lash Blast Volume Mascara claims to increase volume by up to ten times—sans clumping or flaking. Plus, the cruelty-free formula is Leaping Bunny certified, so that's one more reason to feel good about purchasing this product.

MORE DETAILS
This is the seventh best-selling product on Amazon in the category of mascaras, and it's available in other colors too.


Clinique High Impact Mascara In Black/Brown

Overall Score

4.7

09

Clinique High Impact Mascara In Black/Brown

4.55

12879 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

3

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Brown Mascara For Sensitive Eyes

WHAT TO KNOW
Get the length you've been looking for with Clinique's High Impact Mascara. This highly-reviewed mascara promises to provide bold, lush lashes in a few swipes. PS: It's also available in a mini size.

MORE TO KNOW
If you have sensitive skin or eyes, you'll be thrilled to hear that this brown mascara is ophthalmologist- and allergy-tested, and it's also free of mineral oil and fragrances.


Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara In Crystal

Overall Score

4.75

08

Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara In Crystal

4.3

34723 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Tubing Brown Mascara

WHAT TO KNOW
Thrive Causemetics' Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara features the brand's Flake-Free Tubing Technology. Essentially, this technology works by wrapping each lash in a protective "tube" of product, contributing to dramatic length from the root to the tip.

PROMISING REVIEW
"I have been using ONLY this mascara for about two years. Every once in a while, I cave and buy a drugstore mascara and there is NO comparison. This is so easy to apply, and in seconds you have gorgeous long lashes. It does not clump. It does not smudge. It comes off with a warm washcloth in the shower the next morning. It is the only mascara I will use."

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Maybelline New York Great Lash Mascara In Brownish Black

Overall Score

4.75

07

Maybelline New York Great Lash Mascara In Brownish Black

4.32

31232 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

3

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Affordable Brown Mascara

WHAT TO KNOW
Combine a lash-building brush with a lash-lengthening formula and you get Maybelline's Great Lash Mascara. There's a reason this product has been around for years—it's one of the most effective mascaras you can get for an affordable price.

MORE TO KNOW
In addition to the Brownish Black shade featured here, this mascara is available in Black and Very Black.


L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Makeup Lash Paradise Mascara In Washable Black Brown

Overall Score

4.75

06

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Makeup Lash Paradise Mascara In Washable Black Brown

4.37

118976 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

3

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Drugstore Brown Mascara

WHAT TO KNOW
Smudge-, clump-, and flake-proof, the Lash Paradise Mascara is a drugstore fan favorite. For less than $8, this product promises to give voluptuous volume and intense length.

PROMISING REVIEW
"I have always been a Maybelline girl, but I think I have jumped boat. This mascara is easy to apply, doesn't clump, looks good all day, makes my lashes look thicker, and washes off easily with soap and water. Even though it is washable, it does not smudge throughout the day. When I wash my face at night, my eyelashes look just as good as they did when I put it on. LOVE!"


Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara In Uninhibited Brown

Overall Score

4.8

05

Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara In Uninhibited Brown

4.49

19975 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Brown Mascara With Extra Large Brush

WHAT TO KNOW
Add a little luxury to your routine via YSL's Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara. With an extra large brush to ensure even product distribution, this mascara claims to provide 200% more volume and up to 24 hours of smudge-proof wear.

MORE DETAILS
If you're in the mood for a fun makeup look, try the Electric Blue version of this mascara. 


Glossier Lash Slick In Brown

Overall Score

4.8

04

Glossier Lash Slick In Brown

4.25

4917 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

4

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Lengthening Brown Mascara

WHAT TO KNOW
One of Glossier's best sellers, the Lash Stick is a no-fuss option for those who want well-defined, featherlight lashes. The formula includes vegan biotin, an addition that helps soften lashes over time, as well as natural shine polymers that help contribute to an eye-catching finish.

PROMISING REVIEW
"This mascara is perfect, and I am so happy I found it! It gives a clean, non-clumpy, natural effect. I love the price point too...it's about $10 less than the others I have tried that were NOT GOOD."

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free


Saie Mascara 101 In Brown

Overall Score

4.9

03

Saie Mascara 101 In Brown

4.57

1325 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Nourishing Brown Mascara

WHAT TO KNOW
A combination of beeswax, shea butter, and a mineral-rich complex come together to create this highly-nourishing, clean mascara from Saie. Plus, the applicator features a molded brush specifically designed to provide a clump-free, defined finish.

MORE DETAILS
Unlike some of the 'black brown' options on this list, this mascara comes in a true brown tone that's describes as "rich and warm."

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free

Clean Beauty

Clean Beauty


Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing & Lengthening Mascara In Chocolate

Overall Score

4.9

02

Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing & Lengthening Mascara In Chocolate

4

77319 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

5

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Brown Mascara For Bold Lashes

WHAT TO KNOW
A longtime list topper (proof: this one is also on our Top 10 Mascaras list), Too Faced's Better Than Sex Mascara is almost as effective as getting lash extensions. Whether it's the unique hourglass applicator that holds the key or the peptides and polymers in the formula, there's no denying that this product delivers big, bold lashes in a few swipes.

PROMISING REVIEW
"Having short and thin lashes, I can confirm this mascara does magic. It adds great length and volume, as well as curl that stays in place for the entire day. No smudging—not even after gym or with eye cream under."


Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara In Brown

Overall Score

4.95

01

Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara In Brown

4.45

26159 User Reviews

5

Best Seller

4

Industry Recognition

5

Social Buzz

About Our Scoring System

In order for any product to be featured on Rank & Style, it must first meet the requirements set by our algorithm—a vetting process that allocates points based on consumer and industry data to score and rank products within a given category.

Best Brown Mascara Overall

WHAT TO KNOW
If you're looking for a product that'll help create curl (not just length and volume), it doesn't get better than Tarte's Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara. In addition to creating a smudge-proof, flake-free finish, this mascara boasts a 35% increase in lash curl. 

MORE DETAILS
Like all of Tarte's products, this mascara is made with a vegan and cruelty-free formula. 

Cruelty Free

Cruelty Free

View All Top 10 Lists
Arrow white

The Latest

Image credits: sephora

Concealers

Top 10 Concealers

We Used Industry Data To Find The Top 10 Concealers—Here Are The Results

View All Beauty
arrow

From Our Partners

Image credits: pair

Pair Eyewear

Meet Pair Eyewear, a modern, affordable eyewear solution to changing up your frames.

Shop Now

Arrow white

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.